Sep. 6, 2003. 12:34 PM

>ADVERTISEMENT<

BERNARD WEIL/TORONTO STAR

Sometimes to cover Toronto, we have to go halfway around the world. Asim Bukhari is torn between the woman he loves in Canada and the traditions he left behind five years ago when he emigrated from Pakistan to begin a new life in the GTA. A special nine-part story follows his hopes, dreams, struggles and fears.

 

 

 

 

>

 

 

 

>

 

 

 

>

 

 

 

>

 

 

 

>

 

 

>

 

 

 

>

 

 

 

>

 

 

Tradition or love?
Asim Bukhari is getting married. He just doesn't know yet to whom

CATHERINE PORTER

Roaring west along Highway 401 toward the
Nathan Phillips Square celebrations, the Bukhari family shares their New Year's resolutions.

From behind the wheel of their white van, Faheem says he wants to spend more time at home.

His wife, Tabassum, longs to spend more time out of the house.

From the back seat, tucked between his two dozing nieces, 30-year-old Asim Bukhari offers up his goal for 2003.

"I'm going to get married."

To whom?

He pauses, staring out into the chilly Toronto night.

"I don't know."

Asim does know how he's going to do it though. The same way his older brother Faheem did 10 years ago and his younger brother Kazim only last summer. An arranged marriage.

He will call his sisters halfway around the world in the sprawling city of Karachi, Pakistan.

First, they will make the necessary inquiries and phone calls, selecting the bridal candidates like shiny perfect shells on the beach. Then, he will fly "back home" to Karachi, talk to their families over cups of sweet milk tea and plates of crispy meat pastries, and after weighing his options, make his choice.

If her parents choose him too, they will be feeding one another Pakistani sweets on their wedding night within three weeks.

"Then, I won't feel lonely," he says. "I'll have someone who will listen to me and support me."

It's a familiar yearning, fulfilled, for many, in unfamiliar ways.

This is a story about differences.

It is about customs many of us have grown up with being shuffled like cards and redealt into radically new hands. About looking at our lives differently, learning how others live in different ways that can be as fulfilling as they seem strange.

And fittingly, this is a story about marriage and the different ways people approach an institution that is one of the most basic, the most challenging and ultimately the most enriching in any society. The notion of marriage is one of humanity's constants: we all hope to find our soulmates. But, as we will see during Asim's voyage over the next eight days, the practice of it is a tapestry we often weave differently, adapting to the pattern of our own times, culture, hopes and dreams.

Canada has, in the family of nations, a unique way of treating newcomers. It embraces them, and believes they help make this country a richer place by sharing their heritage rather than discarding it. It's an understanding at the heart of many a good marriage.

So, that much said, what do we know about Asim Bukhari?

He stands 5 foot 10, has milky brown skin that darkens at his neck and elbows, weighs 150 pounds and wears jeans, checkered shirts with collars and small, square rimless glasses to frame his almost black eyes.

Like many new immigrants to this country, he lives in two worlds — the "back home" of his childhood, where people define themselves through family and honour, and his new home of Canada, where people are driven by the motto that a career, a home, a life — anything can be remade at a moment's notice. In one world, the elders are revered and the young are "children" who don't make decisions on their own. In the other, youth and independence are idolized, and their grandparents are shuffled off to old-age homes.

But first, his first home. Asim was born on March 2, 1972, into an enormous family by Canadian standards. He falls in the middle of his two brothers and after all seven of his sisters, the eldest of whom, Rizvana, held his warm, squirming body in her 16-year-old arms.

When he was still all arms and legs, Asim's favourite place to sleep on muggy Karachi nights was the flat roof of the house his father built in the crowded edges of what was then the country's capital. His father's job at the Pakistani Railway's storage department wasn't enough to float such a large family, so they rented out two floors and kept the three rooms on the ground floor to themselves. At night, while his siblings laid claim to different patches of floor and corners of beds, he'd escape upstairs to a wooden cot and fall asleep with his head in the clouds.

Asim has always been a dreamer. He sleeps through morning appointments, absent-mindedly forgets lists, makes decisions one minute only to undo them the next. He is easily influenced and very sentimental.

His family says his quick temper comes from the red pepper flakes he showers on his food. He loves Clint Eastwood movies and maple walnut ice cream. He is shy around strangers, but once he knows you, watch out for his caustic wit and playful humour. He'll think nothing of tying a bright scarf around his head and jiggling to the beat while everyone else watches.

He was clearly his mother's favourite.

The Bukhari family's exodus to Canada began 15 years ago. Faheem, the eldest son, was sponsored as a landed immigrant by his childhood neighbours who had moved to Scarborough. He was smaller and thinner then, a student activist in Pakistan who had been badly beaten up by an opposing group on the university campus. His broken jaw was wired shut for two months. To him, Canada promised democracy and prosperity.

Eight years later, he was followed by his sister Saima, who was joining her husband in Pickering. It had been an arranged marriage.

And then, in 1998, it was Asim's turn. Faheem, head of the family since their father's death, had sponsored both his brothers and their mother.

So, on a steaming summer night, Asim jostled through Karachi's potholed streets in a rented van toward the airport, his suitcases jammed full with presents for his brother, a leather jacket for the chilly Canadian winter and his dreams for the future. They landed at Pearson airport on July 3 — two days after Canada Day.

The first thing they noticed about their new country was the orderly way traffic moved on Highway 401.

"You have a lane and no one can come in it. That's amazing. And the cars were going so fast. I was shouting to Faheem to be careful," Kazim says breathlessly from the Bukhari living room couch, beneath a framed photograph of his own wedding day last summer. At 27, he is the youngest of the Bukhari clan and the most talkative.

Driving on Canadian highways was one of the few things Faheem left out in the home movies he mailed home regularly — a kind of "Canada for Dummies" to prepare his brothers. Here is a Canadian school bus, he'd say zooming into its yellow form. And here is a typical Canadian mall. The sales assistants won't bargain with you. And look at this. This is a microwave. You use it instead of a stove to heat things up. See, I'm going to put this cup of milk inside, press 30 seconds and then "start" and watch how it works.

The Bukhari brothers felt assimilated long before touching down on the landing strip.

"Faheem used to joke that we were already in Canada, only resting in Pakistan," says Asim.

They moved into Faheem's new rose-bricked home in a Pickering subdivision, with broad, paved streets that wouldn't turn to muddy rivers in the rainy season.

There were concrete banks called sidewalks where people could walk without the threat of passing vehicles. But you hardly needed them. The streets were so quiet. There were no nasal shouts of subzi wallahs, pushing their wooden carts with vegetables for sale. No motorized rickshaws, buzzing on three wheels around corners. No little boys stripped to the waist, playing cricket with tennis balls wrapped in electric tape in the rain.

Instead of the sugar-cane vendors who crushed the tall stalks into juice at their wooden, road-side stands, there was Tim Hortons. Instead of tailors in small stalls who pulled the measuring tape from around their necks to check your waist and shoulders before stitching up cotton pants and flowing shirts, there was Sears.

For the first time, they each had a room of their own, a car of their own.

There were some details that would take getting used to. For instance, women sat beside men on the buses without anyone even noticing. Gay men paraded down the street; straight men didn't hold hands in public.

Asim has hidden the photographs of his friends hugging each other in the ocean just outside of Karachi at the back of his album, tucked behind less incriminating pictures. In some of them, men hold each other tenderly from behind.

"Over here, they think you are gay," he says, eyes widening as he pulls them out. He hasn't examined these photos for years. "When I look at these pictures, I am shocked. My reaction is `What are they doing?' Five years makes a big difference."

At 26, Asim had a commerce degree and was a computer teacher at a Karachi high school. He dreamed of becoming as successful as Faheem, who was now running four computer and electronics stores of his own.

But Asim's luck wasn't as good. His mother fell ill with pancreatic cancer. Barely three months after they had arrived, he took her back home.

He returned a year later in mourning and enrolled in the computer science program at George Brown College.

The timing couldn't have been worse when he graduated two years later, in August, 2001. Nortel Networks was crashing, signalling the tailspin of the high-tech sector. Every company he called told him the same thing, "We are not hiring right now, but we will keep you in mind."

So, he began working full-time at his brother's stores.

It was then that he met Farah. She was one of his friend's classmates at York University.

One day, after his friend's car broke down and he called Asim for a lift, the three of them went out for a coffee.

It was the way she spoke Urdu that snagged Asim. Although her family also came from Karachi, they were from a different culture. They spoke Sindhi, not Urdu.

"She didn't know how to pronounce words," says Asim. "It was cute."

In some ways, she was more North American than Pakistani. She had been living in Canada since she was 9.

"I used to joke with her and say, `Shut up.' She'd say, `You shut up.' I'd say, `If you were a Pakistani girl, you'd just keep quiet. You don't have the right. You are a woman.' She'd go, `So, I'm not a Pakistani girl. I'm not going to shut up when you say shut up,'" he says smiling, pulling out two photos from his wallet. They were taken in a booth at Cedarbrae Mall. Their cheeks are pressed together and both their eyes squinting as they laugh.

They began to see one another in secret — calling each other's pagers and setting up meetings in coffee shops or along the lakeshore. He'd often take her to a park near his house to sit with their legs hanging over a cliff.

He never phoned her at home. That was an unspoken understanding. Her parents would be livid. They were of the opinion that good Pakistani girls do not date. Neither do good Pakistani boys, for that matter. It would bring dishonour to the family name.

(To protect her honour, Asim has asked that her real name not be used. Farah is a pseudonym.)

So, even after he proposed to her in the middle of a coffee shop, he didn't reveal his feelings to Faheem until the subject of marriage was raised one night six months later.

Dishing out the meal his wife Tabassum had cooked that afternoon, Faheem announced it was time for Asim to get married. He was 30. He had no responsibilities. He lived in Faheem's home, paid no rent, worked in his shop.

"What is he waiting for?" says Faheem, 37.

If they could find a nice girl here they would. Otherwise, he should return to Pakistan and find a bride, as Faheem had 10 years ago, choosing his cousin and bringing her back to Pickering a year later.

Asim gathered the courage to announce he already had a girl in mind. He wanted Faheem, as the head of the Bukhari household, to approach Farah's family the appropriate way — with a formal proposal for marriage.

The night in February they drove over to Farah's Scarborough home was cold and windy. The temperature fell below minus 10. The van windows fogged up. Tabassum bundled up their newborn baby girl, Fathima, for the trip. They stopped at Tim Hortons on the way for a chocolate forest cake.

The meeting did not go well.

Her parents said little over the meal, while Farah ran back and forth to the kitchen with steaming plates of chicken curry and warm chapatis. Faheem brought up the issue of marriage twice. They didn't bite.

Before they left, Faheem provided Farah's parents with all his telephone numbers — home, work, cell. If they had any questions about Asim, he'd be happy to oblige.

They never called.

"Her mother was mad. She said, `How dare you get a proposal? You are just 21 years old. You are not supposed to get married. You are supposed to be studying,'" says Asim.

"Her mom said I wasn't highly educated. They are looking for a highly educated guy, with a very good job. Not someone who is working at his brother's store. Plus, there's the cultural thing, too."

Not only was he not Sindhi, he was a mohajir, an immigrant. His parents had come to Pakistan from India soon after partition in 1947 to participate in the new Muslim democracy.

After two weeks, when the Bukhari phone had not rung, the family took it as a rejection.

"Basically, people don't say no. If they don't call you, they don't get back to you, it means no," says Asim.

It was time to accept tradition and go back to Pakistan.

The months passed. Asim decided to switch careers and enrolled in an accounting program at Centennial College.

He quietly hoped.

When Farah told him that her mother was back in Pakistan, he called his older sister Najma, — who everyone affectionately calls Aapi, Urdu for older sister — and asked if she would approach her there. Soon after, he received a phone call from Farah's father. He wanted to meet Asim again.

There was another trip to Farah's home, this time alone. And a following phone call peppering Faheem with more questions.

Asim knew from his own sisters' marriages that a girl's family had to carefully investigate every marriage proposal before accepting.

But this was crossing the line. His family's honour was at stake.

"How many times we went there and they would never come to my house," he says indignantly. "My sisters said, `You know they're not going to let her marry you, so why allow them to disrespect you and your family?'"

He was heartbroken. So was Farah. They both wept on the phone. He asked if she would go against her parents' wishes. She wouldn't. He understood that. Neither would he. Family is to Pakistani culture what freedom is to North Americans.

Dejected, he called Aapi in Karachi and told her to find him a bride.

"I played my game and I lost. So now you do it," he told her. He'd marry any girl she lined up for him. He could even do it over the phone like a family friend in Pickering had done.

Faheem stepped in. He persuaded Asim to at least fly back and meet the girl first.

"He said, `This is not a joke. Maybe you think you can do it now, but when you get married, there are lots of things you might not like in her. How she laughs, how she talks,'" Asim says. "I realized he is right."

That was last winter.

Since then, Asim has turned 31. A month after his birthday, he was sworn in as a Canadian citizen in an Oshawa courtroom. (The judge didn't shake his hand because of the SARS scare.) He became a part-time student, and got his first Canadian work experience outside his brother's stores — one 10-day clerical contract at a downtown law firm, and another four-month stint doing accounting work at a Markham insurance agency.

He made plans to return to Karachi in July and tried to forget Farah. With each passing week and each phone conversation with Aapi, he grew increasingly excited.

What would happen? In a few months, would he be married? What would his wife be like?

His only stipulation was that she be educated.

That way she could adapt to Canadian life more easily. And he'd like her to have long hair, like Farah.

"If it's not, that's not a problem. I'm not picky," he says.

His family has a more detailed wish list. Asim's bride should be a rational person, to measure his impulsiveness, his younger brother says. She should be as good at saving money as he is at spending it, says his older brother. She should be patient and have a good memory, as everyone in the family is forgetful, his sister offers quietly.

She should be competent, says his sister-in-law Tabassum, emptying rice out of a large metal pot in the family kitchen. She chooses each word tentatively. After nine years here, she still isn't comfortable with the strange, hard-sounding language.

"I think he is a baby," she says. "He doesn't make decisions for himself."

Five days before he is set to leave, Asim goes shopping with Tabassum, his sister Saima and their toddlers, Fathima and the excitable Samir.

The first stop is Moores Clothing For Men. Red balloons dot the air-conditioned store. There is a clearance sale. While both women sink shyly into the background tending to their babies, Asim flies around the store like a hummingbird.

It takes him less than four minutes to choose clothes for his wedding reception: a black, Italian silk-lined three-button suit. He stands before the mirror, nods his head and mumbles softly that he will take it.

He selects a pair of black, laceless dress shoes, approves a reversible leather belt, examines the quality of a bundle of dress socks. He quickly picks out a wedding tie and shirt, and just as quickly changes his mind when Tabassum points out the combination she likes better.

A half hour later, the total flashes from the store's cash register: $1,019.90. Asim pulls out a white envelope from his pocket, filled with crisp $50 and $20 bills he withdrew from the bank that morning.

They return to a buzzing home, where Asim's nieces and nephews are finishing their dusk prayers on small rugs rolled out on the kitchen floor. They rip through his bags.

With Fathima squirming on his lap, Faheem inspects Asim's purchases. His new suit, he is told, is getting altered.

"Black?" Faheem says. "Black is for a funeral."

Asim looks around the room for support. Suddenly, he is unsure. "Should I call them and change it?" he asks.

The night before his flight, Asim stays up late packing. Faheem helps him stock two suitcases with presents for the family. There are Betty Crocker cook sets for his nieces, lipstick and eye shadow for his sisters, Gillette razors and shaving foam for his brothers-in-law, a calculator and sunglasses for his nephews, and super-size boxes of chocolate for anyone he's missed.

They weigh the bags on a bathroom scale to ensure each slips just below the airline's limit. After years of travelling back and forth, they have this down to a refined art. Asim's carry-on knapsack is bursting. He will carry his laptop computer and digital camera with him in the passenger compartment.

"We always carry the maximum," he says. "It's tradition."

He is daydreaming about the upcoming reunion with his sisters when his pager goes off.

It's Farah.

She wants to meet him tomorrow before his plane leaves.

So, the next morning, Asim drives down to a park near her work and sits with her in the car for an hour. She is also travelling to Karachi in a few weeks. Her mother wants to introduce her to a few prospective grooms. But she wants to be with Asim.

When he returns home, his pager goes off again. This time she has sent a text message.

"I love you," it flashes.

The Bukharis are back in the family van, whizzing along the 401. They are seeing Asim off on his voyage. Faheem, again at the wheel, is feeling nostalgic.

Aapi's two daughters are getting married on Aug. 22. They are planning to find Asim a bride by then and hold his wedding reception on the same day. It will be one giant celebration.

"I wish I was going. It could have been a lot of fun," Faheem sighs. But they are moving to a new house in Ajax next month, and he has the stores to attend to.

His two daughters are in the back seat again, along with Saima's daughter, 5-year-old Bisma.

They are playing a game: What will Asim's wife be like.

6-year-old Ifrah: "Friendly. Not crazy either."

7-year-old Ariba: "I want her to be a little bit funny."

Bisma: "What if she has only one eyeball?"

They erupt into giggles.

Asim sits quietly in the front passenger seat. He bites his nails. It's a habit his mother used to scold him for.

He feels nervous. His family puts it down to regular travel squeamishness. And that he is leaving some bills unpaid.

But it's not money that is turning his stomach upside down. It's Farah. The small pilot light of hope has been reignited.

"I still love her," he says. "I'm going to try one last time."

He doesn't know how. He'll ask Aapi in Karachi if she can arrange something. Maybe talk to her parents one final time.

When he steps on to the plane, he wonders what outcome this voyage will bring.

In a month's time, will he be married to a girl he doesn't know yet, but will learn to love? Or will he be married to the girl he already loves?