Categories

Level 4

Level 3

Level 2

Level 1

Knowledge/Understanding

Covers the key topics important to the issue

 

Exceptional presentation of the key topics important to the issue

Good presentation of most of the key topics important to the issue

Somewhat presents the key topics important to the issue

Does not adequately present key topics important to the issue

Thinking

 

Superior  use of facts and evidence 

 

Excellent use of strategies and cost analysis when suggesting implementation of new programs

 

Mechanisms for ensuring implementation are clear and determine accountability

 

 

 

Some use of facts and evidence

 

Adequate use of strategies and cost analysis for implementation of new programs

 

Mechanisms for ensuring implementation are evident

Little use of facts and evidence

 

Shows some use of strategies and cost analysis for implementing new programs

 

Mechanisms for ensuring implementation are only somewhat evident

Limited use of facts and evidence

 

Does not show use of strategies and cost analysis for implementing new programs

 

Mechanisms for ensuring implementation are not clearly evident

Communication

Uses the precise structure required in UN resolution submissions

Heading clearly summarizes the issue

 

Structure of resolution follows all UN guidelines

 

Heading adequately summarizes the issue

 

Structure of resolution follows some UN guidelines

Heading somewhat summarizes the issue

 

Structure of resolution follows few UN guidelines

Heading does not clearly summarize the issue

 

Structure of resolution follows none of the UN guidelines

Application

 

Is the resolution written in the perspective of your country?

Uses Prembulatory/Operative clause language effectively

Are the principles used relevant to the sponsor?

 

Demonstrates superb knowledge about  the perspective of the country submitting the resolution

 

Presents an excellent set of clauses that clearly demonstrate an attempt at achieving international consensus

Demonstrates good knowledge about the perspective of the country submitting the resolution

 

Presents a good set of clauses that clearly demonstrate an attempt at achieving international consensus

Demonstrates limited knowledge about the perspective of the country submitting the resolution

 

Presents a set of clauses that somewhat demonstrate an attempt at achieving international consensus

Demonstrates no knowledge about the perspective of the country submitting the resolution

 

Presents a weak set of clauses that unsuccessfully demonstrate an attempt at achieving international consensus

MUN Resolution Rubric